CheapoTrav
Call

Cheap car rentals in Key West

Compare every major rental brand in Key West — economy, midsize, SUV, and minivan — with all-in pricing and no hidden fees.

Key West, FL, USA· Airport: EYW
Key West — Car rentals | CheapoTrav travel guide

Skip the search — let a CheapoTrav expert do it for you.

Phone-only fares for Key West, 24/7.

Call 1 (815) 473-8090

Key facts

  • All major brands serve Key West including Hertz, Enterprise, Avis, Budget, Alamo
  • Airport pickup typically costs 15–25% more than off-airport but saves a shuttle
  • Free cancellation on most reservations up to pickup time
  • Phone-only corporate rate codes can save 10–20% if you ask
  • Insurance options explained on every CheapoTrav quote

Renting a car in Key West? CheapoTrav compares Hertz, Enterprise, Alamo, Budget, Avis, Sixt, and consolidator inventory in one search. Southernmost point in the US — sunsets, conch, and Hemingway.

Rental prices in Key West change by the hour based on fleet availability, so it's worth checking a few times — and worth knowing the airport vs. downtown rate difference, which can be 20–30%.

Use the search below for live rates, or call the travel desk if you want help picking the right car class and a no-surprises out-the-door price.

In this guide

  • Where to pick up your rental in Key West
  • Average rental rates
  • Hidden fees to watch for
  • Insurance options

Frequently asked questions

What's the cheapest car rental company in Key West?
It changes weekly. Enterprise, Alamo, and Budget are usually the most aggressive on economy rates in Key West, but Sixt and consolidators can win on luxury and SUV classes.
Is it cheaper to rent a car at EYW or downtown?
Off-airport pickup is typically 15–30% cheaper, but you'll spend on a rideshare or shuttle to get there. We can price both options on the phone.
Call 1 (815) 473-8090 for phone-only fares
Do I need to buy the rental company's insurance?
Not usually — most US credit cards include collision damage waiver as a perk, and personal auto insurance may extend to rentals. Confirm with your card and insurer before declining the rental company's CDW.
What is the minimum age to rent a car in Key West?
21 at most agencies in Key West, with a young-driver surcharge of $20–$30/day until age 25. A few brands rent to 18+ in select states.
Call 1 (815) 473-8090 for phone-only fares
Can I drop the car off in a different city?
Yes, but expect a one-way drop fee of $50–$300 depending on distance and destination. Within a single region you can sometimes get it waived.
Should I prepay for fuel?
Almost never. Prepaid-fuel rates assume you return the car empty, which is hard to time. Refilling at the closest gas station is usually $10–$25 cheaper.
Call 1 (815) 473-8090 for phone-only fares

More for travelers visiting Key West

Nearby destinations