CheapoTrav
Call

Cheap car rentals in Key West

Compare every major rental brand in Key West — economy, midsize, SUV, and minivan — with all-in pricing and no hidden fees.

Key West, FL, USA· Airport: EYW
Key West — Car rentals | CheapoTrav travel guide

Skip the search — let a CheapoTrav expert do it for you.

Phone-only fares for Key West, 24/7.

Call (815) 991-4848

Key facts

  • Most rental counters are located directly at Key West International Airport (EYW) for easy pickup and drop-off.
  • Parking in Old Town Key West is limited and can be expensive; many accommodations offer dedicated spaces.
  • Major rental brands like Hertz, Enterprise, Avis, and Budget serve Key West, offering diverse vehicle options.
  • Consider a rental if planning day trips to Bahia Honda State Park or other Upper and Middle Keys destinations.
  • For Old Town exploration, consider alternatives like walking, biking, or the free Duval Loop bus service.
  • Tolls are not a factor on the Overseas Highway (US-1) through the Florida Keys, simplifying travel.
  • Booking in advance, especially during high season (winter/spring), is crucial to secure preferred rates and vehicle types.

Renting a car in Key West, Florida, offers flexibility, though it's important to consider how you plan to use it. Many visitors find Key West’s historic Old Town walkable and bike-friendly, with the Duval Street area and Mallory Square easily accessible on foot or via local transportation like the Duval Loop bus or pedi-cabs. If your plan is to primarily explore the immediate downtown area, a rental car might spend most of its time parked, which can be expensive and challenging to find, particularly during peak season.

However, a car becomes more valuable if you intend to explore beyond the central Key West area. Consider day trips up the Overseas Highway to other Lower Keys such destinations like Bahia Honda State Park, Marathon, or even further north to Islamorada. These excursions offer distinct experiences that are best reached by personal vehicle. Having a car also simplifies logistics if you're staying in a less central area of Key West or have specific activities planned that are off the main tourist routes.

Most car rental agencies operate directly out of Key West International Airport (EYW), making airport pickup a convenient option immediately upon arrival. While rates for airport rentals can sometimes carry a premium, the convenience of bypassing shuttle services or taxis to an off-airport location often outweighs the cost for many travelers. Compare prices from various providers to ensure you're getting a competitive rate for your specific travel dates.

Before committing, assess your itinerary: if it's primarily Old Town, a car might be overkill. If you plan to explore the broader Keys, it's a practical necessity. Factor in parking costs and availability at your accommodation and planned destinations. Remember that traffic can be slow, especially on US-1 during peak hours or events. For personalized assistance, consider speaking with a travel agent who can help navigate these choices.

In this guide

  • Where to pick up your rental in Key West
  • Average rental rates
  • Hidden fees to watch for
  • Insurance options

Frequently asked questions

Is it necessary to rent a car for a trip to Key West?
Whether you need a car in Key West depends on your itinerary. If you plan to spend most of your time exploring Old Town Key West, which is highly walkable and bike-friendly, a car may not be essential. The area is well-served by public transportation options like the Duval Loop bus. However, if you intend to venture to other Keys, visit specific attractions outside the main tourist zone, or prefer the convenience of having your own transport for airport transfers and luggage, a rental car is beneficial. Factor in parking availability and costs at your accommodation.
Where can I rent a car in Key West?
The primary location for car rentals in Key West is Key West International Airport (EYW). Most major rental companies, including Enterprise, Hertz, Avis, Budget, and Alamo, have counters and vehicle pickup directly at the airport terminal. There are also a few off-airport rental locations in town, though their hours might be more limited, and you'll need to arrange transport to reach them. Renting at EYW often offers the most straightforward and convenient experience upon arrival.
Call (815) 991-4848 for phone-only fares
What kind of car is best for driving in Key West and the Keys?
For Key West and the Florida Keys, a standard compact or mid-size sedan is often sufficient. The roads are generally well-maintained, and traffic speeds are moderate. If you plan on extensive scenic drives along the Overseas Highway and prefer a more open-air experience, a convertible can enhance the journey, though they typically cost more. For families or groups needing more space for luggage or passengers, an SUV might be a better choice. Given the generally flat terrain, four-wheel drive is unnecessary.
Are there parking challenges or costs associated with a rental car in Key West?
Yes, parking in Key West, particularly in the Old Town area, can be challenging and costly. On-street parking is often metered or reserved for residents, with strict enforcement. Many hotels and guesthouses offer limited guest parking, which may incur an additional fee. Public parking garages are available but can fill up quickly, especially during peak season or events, and rates can be high. If your accommodation does not include parking, factor in these potential expenses and the time spent searching for a spot when considering a rental.
Call (815) 991-4848 for phone-only fares
Is it more expensive to rent a car at Key West Airport (EYW) versus off-airport?
Typically, car rentals at Key West International Airport (EYW) might have slightly higher base rates or include additional airport concession fees compared to some off-airport locations. However, the convenience of picking up your vehicle immediately upon arrival and dropping it off directly before departure often outweighs the marginal cost difference for many travelers. Off-airport locations might require a taxi or shuttle ride to reach, adding to your overall expense and travel time. Compare total costs, including transport to off-airport sites, before deciding.
Can I drive a rental car from Key West to mainland Florida?
Yes, you can absolutely drive a rental car from Key West to mainland Florida. The Overseas Highway (US-1) connects Key West to the mainland, providing a continuous scenic route. All major car rental companies allow their vehicles to be driven throughout Florida and typically across state lines within the U.S. There are no special restrictions for this route, and it's a common practice for travelers to combine a Key West visit with other Florida destinations. Just ensure your rental agreement covers the duration of your entire trip.
Call (815) 991-4848 for phone-only fares

More for travelers visiting Key West

Nearby destinations